Season 2: Redemption

GABE: “ You want to talk about it? It’s just you hardly said a word the whole ride

CATHERINE: “I guess I just feel bad, that’s all. It’s nothing, really.
I’m okay.”

GABE: “Hey, I thought we decided that we were gonna be honest with
each other”

Catherine doesn’t even want to talk with Gabe about how she felt about
shooting Jacob! It seems like something you would feel comfortable discussing
with your partner, especially if they experienced the same thing. But it takes
Gabe, to chide her that they need to be honest with each other, for her to say
anything about it. It wasn’t like that with Vincent, they were discussing it
outside Sam’s loft before Gabe showed up. So that indicates where Catherine is